Not only am I nearly so pale that I almost glow in the dark, but I also have rosacea (a skin disorder that makes me ruddy to florid, depending on the day). To help out the drugs I take for the rosacea, I need to protect my skin from the sun as much as possible. Along with this lovely combo of facts, also consider that I take not one but two other drugs (for unrelated conditions) that also increase sun sensitivity. The result is skin that can burn while I walk from the house to my car. It's not pretty, and it isn't a lot of fun.
I've tried just about every sunscreen out there, and to be honest, they all work just fine for me as long as there is a physical sun protection agent in the product -- something like titanium dioide or zinc oxide.
What sets them apart to me is one thing: how do they feel on my skin? I hate the feeling of gooky, gloppy stuff on my skin, and having it on my face is enough to make me perfectly miserable. I don't wear foundation makeup for this reason -- it feels like a kabuki mask, and I don't like it. Also, in my experience, the more slippery the sunscreen, the more likely it is to run into my eyes.
I have been wearing sunscreen because I don't like the results when I don't, but I haven't been liking it until the past couple of weeks while I've been using a product that's new to me: Colorescience Pro Sunforgettable SPF 30 powder sunscreen. I love this stuff.
The shade I use is called "fair" on some sites, and "All Clear" on others. There is also a shimmer version, but I haven't tried that (shimmer face stuff seems very middle-school to me, and I'm approaching 50.) It has no tint at all that I can discern, but it also doesn't seem to make me look paler than I already am. I wouldn't pick this shade if you want to look "sun kissed," but it is also available in a number of different tints.
Best of all, it's comfortable. When I'm wearing it, I don't think about it, which is all I really want from a face product. It keeps me from burning, and the self-contained brush-topped container is small enough to bring along for reapplication. Now, I haven't tried this stuff out at the beach or anything, but for just tooling around the neighborhood on a walk or riding in the car (where I have gotten some of my worst sunburns), it works perfectly.
I note on their site that there is also an SPF 50 formulation, but the SPF 30 seems to be perfect for my needs. It also looks like the brush powder is only one part of a complete system that Colorescience is recommending, but I've been using the powder alone and will probably continue to do so.
If you need to wear other skin treatments at the same time, like I do, you'll know that many sunscreens seem to grab at other products and roll everything up into little balls of residue, sort of like used eraser crumbles on your SAT bubble form. This product doesn't do that; it just glides on and sits on top of whatever else you've got on your face at the moment.
It isn't inexpensive: the brush applicator/product combo costs about $50.00 everywhere I've found it. However, once you've got the brush, the refills are about $20, which is in line with what I expect to pay for sunscreen. Honestly, given how much money I've spent on sunscreen just to throw it out unused because I hated it, this stuff would have been cheap if I'd found it earlier.
I've never seen this product in a store, but it's pretty easy to find online everywhere from Amazon to Drugstore.com. Hope you like it as much as I do.